
<6>
With a fixed clock frequency, they can only take a sample step every 48 or
96KHz and step at that increment. This only simulates fractional delay and
is not true fractional delay. The ear can hear the difference, and so the brain
will process this difference as incorrect. Early digital delays like the
Lexicon PCM 41/42 did use a variable clock using a different, now
obsolete, process. However, these were the exception, not the rule. Most
digitally controlled analog delay based modulation that use a processor-
generated clock do not use steps small enough for true fractional delay.
Therefore, while they may use a BBD, the modulation does not sound as
natural as some picosecond step clocks or true analog modulation.
In addition, BBDs have some other “artifacts” that give them their unique
sound. The transfer characteristics, gain, noise, distortion, and frequency
response vary depending on the bias voltage and clock frequency making
the sound change as the delay time changes. They also do not put out the
entire signal at the same time. Half the signal is a ½ clock behind the rest
of the signal, yet combined at the same time, making for a strange, smeared
mixing of the signal samples slightly out of time.
Other components in a BBD circuit are also responsible for the signature
sound of analog delays. BBDs require companding and emphasis/de-
emphasis networks to improve the signal to noise ratio, but these add phase
changes, limiting and an animated “breathing” compression character to the
sound. The design of the filters affects the frequency response, peaking or
ringing, and potential aliasing or ring modulation. There are many more
parts of the analog design often overlooked in digital recreations that affect
the sound as well. This includes the clipping, feedback network, clock
stability, modulation wave shaping/curves (exponential or linear, etc.) that
are all important to get that great analog sound.
For more reading about BBDs check out these great websites:
https://www.electrosmash.com/mn3007-bucket-brigade-devices
https://www.premierguitar.com/articles/25035-behind-the-bucket-brigade
https://pedals.thedelimagazine.com/bbd-chips-the-magic-behind-analog-delay-
pedals/