
CHAPTER 2
Operation 11
2.2.4 Comparison Method
This method applies when it is not possible to move the machine, but when a similar location
may be found for Type 4204. This requires a diffuse sound field in the part of the room where
the sound pressure measurement is to be performed. A method for checking whether the sound
field is diffuse is normally given in the standards. If this is the case, sound pressure level
measurements may be carried out on the machine as in section 2.2.3.
Most standards and codes of practice give tables where the correction factor may be found as a
function of the difference between the levels measured with and without the machine in
operation. The minimum difference below which no data should be reported is normally also
specified. (In the case of ISO 3741 this is 6 dB). The correction factors K(to be subtracted
from the measured sound pressure level) and minimum differences specified by ISO 3741 and
ASHRAE 36-72 are given as an example in Table 2.1.
The reference sound source should then be placed in a location similar to that of the machine as
far as reflections, etc., are concerned. With Type 4204 operating and the machine stopped, the
sound pressure level of Type 4204 may be measured and the sound power level of the machine
derived from eq. (2.1).
Again, the required number and position of the measuring points, test conditions, etc., are
stated in the relevant standard.
2.2.5 Juxtaposition Method
If it is not possible to use the substitution or comparison method, the juxtaposition method may
be used. Sound pressure level measurements are first carried out with the machine operating.
The machine is then stopped and Type 4204 is placed against or on the machine (several
positions for Type 4204 may be necessary when more than one sound source is identified in the
machine).
This method is not as accurate as the two previous methods and can only be used as an
approximate survey of the machine. One reason is, that the sound power output of the reference
source depends on the surroundings (see section 3.9).
The three methods have been described and compared to the direct measurement method in an
article entitled “The Use of a Reference Sound Source in Studying Industrial Noise”, by
P. Francois and D. de Montussaint, Inter-Noise 72 Proceedings, Washington D.C., October
4 – 6, 1972.