DVD: The Incredibles
(parallel placement)
During the “100 Mile Dash” chapter
the surrounds were engaged in overdrive.
Environments were summersive and Dash
frequently showed up in the surround
tracks as did the flying vehicles. In the
ending battle scene against the giant robot
there was a lot of “off-screen” action which
was well represented directionally by the
YSP-1100.This scene in general is excellent
testing material for surround effects and
making sure you are correctly configured
for 5.1. I would have to say that parallel
placement won this round as well – the
room simply did much better and having
the option of 5Beam mode and Stereo +
3Beam was a plus. The difference in having
the 5Beam mode was amazing. The front
left and right channels were separated
in a much wider soundstage – so much
so that the system was able to position
these channels at the extreme edges of my
Stewart projector screen – that’s about
four feet outside of and the same amount
higher than the edges of the YSP-1100.
What’s possibly more impressive was that
the perception was that the sound was
coming from behind the Yamaha, which was
positioned in a temporary spot 1.5 feet in
front of the screen.
DVD: Hero
(corner placement)
On this DVD I
wanted something
a bit more epic
that could allow
me to hear more
of a feature film
mix of production
audio and sound
design. There
are also some
excellent scenes
where surround sound is fantastically
demonstrated. Chapter 7 “Advance Ten
Paces” has a well-known scene where Jet
Li’s character takes out an entire room of
bamboo in the blink of an eye.The YSP-1100
recreated this in an almost eerie manner.
With no direct radiating speakers the effect
was of being in the room itself. Instead of
surround sound it was more of a “real”
sound that literally came from all directions.
The right side was still a bit weak due to my
room, but I looked forward to re-evaluating
the setup in the next room with a parallel
installation and four solid walls to utilize the
5Beam system.
The following chapter “Flying Snow”
was even more impressive, with falling
wooden arrows that literally came down
from everywhere. I found that if I leaned
forward or back the imaging would change,
but that is where configuring the system
properly comes into play.Most of the sound
was locate in front of the seating position
slightly, but the effect was still immersive.
DVD: Hero
(parallel placement)
This was a night and day difference.With
the system set up in parallel mode in my first
reference system (with all acoustical panels
removed) the effects of the YSP-1100 were
nothing short of breathtaking.To get this type
of surround sound presence from a single
box is absolutely astonishing. In Chapter 7,
Jet Li floats around the room and the sound
of the bamboo breaking is unmistakably real.
In addition, the height adjustments made by
the Auto Setup rendered the final sequence
where he catches the cup on his sword
perfect – the cup sounded as if it landed
directly on the sword – in the middle of
my 100-inch screen. Keep in mind that the
Yamaha Digital Sound Projector is situated
about 1.5 feet below the bottom of the
projector screen.
During“Flying Snow” it sounded again as if
the wooden arrows fell all around the room
– however this time the soundstage was
immense. In addition the sound extended
to beyond the seated position, unlike in the
other reference room with a corner install.
Viewing this allowed me to realize that the
system could be optimized in a myriad of
rooms, however the more rectangular you
can get it, the better your overall results will
be (this corresponds to suggestions made
within the user manual as well).
Recommendations
Making recommendations to a company
like Yamaha is tough – they almost seem
clairvoyant in their ability to provide new
products with advanced features and
bug-free performance. The Auto Setup is
acceptable on this system, but users may
have trouble with corner placement. It
would be cool to have a “lock-down”
mode whereby the type of setup (corner
or parallel) is selected as part of the setup
process.Then the system can calibrate from
that fixed position and information.
Lastly, we’d like to see a flagship model
with component video upconversion and
an on-screen display that doesn’t limit itself
to the composite video outputs only. HDMI
would be nice as well, but I don’t see it as
a necessity with this style of product – at
least not right now.A backlit remote rounds
out my suggestions and completes this
short “shopping list” of suggestions.
If you’re planning on using this in your
room for home theater or more than just
occasional casual listening, we recommend
a subwoofer.The included TruBass feature is
nice and it does add some lower frequency
perception, but you can’t beat a real
subwoofer (or two). Adding a sub really
completes this system and brings it to the
next level – so make sure you add that to
your list.
“Ocean” features acoustic bass and a gentle
guitar intro with solid, heavily reverberant,
vocals. As the reverb is natural and not an
effects box, this was a good demonstration
of the YSP-1100’s best effort to fill my
reference system with a nice, smooth and
reverberant sound. It accomplished the
goal and soundstaging was wide and open.
Nothing seemed out pf place or forced by
the system. Yamaha seems to have found a
very natural method of steering the channel
information where it needs to go. As with
the other discs, a parallel setup was clearly
superior to the corner placement – again
due to the wider front soundstage which
is hard to reproduce in Stereo + 3Beam
mode.
DVD: Marillion
Marbles on the Road
(corner
placement)
Marillion is cool.
They just walk out
onto stage when
they play – no
fanfare needed,
just excellent
performances and
talented musicians.
From the opening
number, crowd noise filled the room –
though it didn’t quite make it behind me
– likely due to the corner placement and
room/wall issues. The 5.1 Dolby Digital
track on this DVD is a “stage mix” where
you are in the audience, so everything is
pretty much up front with ambience and
crowds in the “surrounds.” For this type of
music, the Yamaha seemed to do very well.
Steve Hogarth’s voice was clear and natural.
Drums and cymbals came through with a
nice edge and no audible distortion or lack
of upper midrange. Guitars had a good clean
and crisp top end and the synths seemed to
exude a gentle reverb that leaked into the
listening room along with the watery vocals
of the first track,“The Invisible Man”.
“You’re Gone” is one of my favorite tunes
and man did it sound good on the Yamaha.
With the room full of Hogarth’s lyrics and
the melodic guitar line following through in
crisp detail I thought this was one of the
coolest ways I had yet experienced this
disc. When the chorus kicked into its jazzy
crescendo I felt the overall presence in the
room step up a notch. The mix took on a
fuller feel and the YSP-1100 reacted to the
additional surround info and poured it into
the listening environment.
DVD: Marillion
Marbles on the Road
(parallel placement)
On this disc the surrounds were not
changed as much – crowd noise was still
well-place and evident from the opening of
the song through each interlude. The front
imaging, again, was much more convincing
and realistic. The 5Beam mode is clearly
a winner here and it does amazing things
with music DVDs. As Marillion’s Steve
Hogarth sings the opening track in his sultry
voice, bass and synthesized guitar effects
permeated the room and generated a very
full mix. As I skipped to “You’re Gone” I
realized that I hadn’t really checked out the
DSP modes of the YSP-1100. I tried out the
various Music modes and made some notes
(you can switch back and forth from each
mode and “Off” quite easily):
• Concert Hall: Adds more front channel
information into the surrounds and
also adds a reverberant delay.The
front vocal is a bit less “centered”
with the DSP on and it seems to get
sent, to a greater degree, into the left
and right channels.
• Jazz Club: Vocals remained anchored
in the front center of the soundstage,
though they were pulled a tad into the
surrounds. Guitars were more present
in the surrounds and the soundstage
appeared to be a bit wider overall.
It is a good effect and does seem to
recreate a more “live” environment
without bringing in too mush reverb.
• Music Video: This DSP mode seemed
to almost squash the sound a tiny
bit. In a sense it decreased the sound
stage and the overall fidelity – which
I suppose would blend quite well
with many of today’s pathetically
obtuse and poor quality music videos.
This mode had the least effect on
the original sound.
Listening Tests - Movies
I utilized the Manual setup since I had
a corner placement setup at the start of
evaluation (I’ll actually be evaluating the
system in two reference systems – so take
note of my setup details). Auto Setup did
not correctly configure the system as being
in a corner-oriented installation, so I was
unable to use the auto setup.
DVD: The Incredibles
(corner placement)
I queued up
Chapter 23 “100
Mile Dash” to see
howwell thecorner
configuration
would work with
the surround-
heavy material in
this section of the
movie. Right off the
bat my observations through the manual
setup process were also discerned by the
listening tests.The surround left channel was
almost impeccable. Sounds coming from the
rear were not nearly as impressive though
the overall envelopment was excellent. As
Dash runs across the water and enters the
cavern the ambience correctly changes and
you could almost “feel” it in the room (this
happened again a short while later when
Violet produces a bubble which saves them
from the gunfire. In the ensuing family battle
against the spinning ships, envelopment
was almost total, with only a slight lack of
presence on the right side due to my lack of
a full side wall and corner placement. Keep
in mind that in this first pass the system was
operating in Stereo + 3Beam mode (the
only option for surround sound with corner
placement).
Overall the effect is a bit uncanny.Switching
between stereo and Stereo + 3Beam really
allows you to hear what the YSP-1100 is
doing. It’s a feeling of surround envelopment
without point sources. Whereas dipole
speakers attempt to diffuse surround fields,
the Digital Sound Projector completely
achieves this goal.
“I was very impressed by theYSP-1100’s build quality.
The non-removable grill cover of the YSP-1100 is made
of steel that is carefully designed not to ring or rattle.
If this unit were designed any sturdier it would be
suitable for military use.”
Clint DeBoer