8?GD?EC5D89C7E945
DXYcWeYTU`b_fYTUcRbYUVY^cdbeSdY_^cV_bdXUS_]]_^\i
ecUTVUQdebUcQfQY\QR\UgYdXdXU
CE@5BC5D$#
dU\U`X_^UC_]U_VdXUcUVUQdebUcQbUQSSUccUTRiecY^W
dXUVe^SdY_^[Uic_^i_ebdU\U`X_^U9^dXUY^cdbeSdY_^cY^
dXYcWeYTUdXUVe^SdY_^[UicQbUbU`bUcU^dUTRie``UbSQcU
g_bTcUW=5CC175
DXUcYhR\eUC_Vd[Uic_^i_ebdU\U`X_^UcUdQ\\_gi_ed_
QSSUcc]Q^i]_bUdU\U`X_^UVUQdebUcDXUcU[UicQbU
e^\QRU\UTRUSQecUdXUYbVe^SdY_^cSQ^SXQ^WUDXU
CE@5B;5IVe^SdY_^[UiQ\\_gci_ed_QSSUccdXU]Q^i
Ve^SdY_^cQfQY\QR\U_^dXUc_Vd[Uic9^dXUY^cdbeSdY_^cY^
dXYcWeYTUdXUc_Vd[Ui\QRU\cdXQdQ``UQbY^dXU=QY^4Yc`\Qi
QbU`bUcU^dUTY^YdQ\YSdUhdUW
=UccQWY^W
:Thb8]SXRPc^abP]S3Xb_[Phb
BD?4A:4H)
V_b`b_WbQ]]Y^W@Ubc_^Q\;UicQc
C`UUT3Q\\;UicQSSUccY^W]_cdcUdVUQdebUcQ^T
TYc`\QiY^WcUdY^V_b]QdY_^
!
B^UcZThb
R\eU[Uice^TUbdXU=QY^4Yc`\Qi
)
V_b
`UbV_b]Y^WdXUS_]]Q^TccX_g^Y^dXU=QY^4Yc`\Qi
"
?Tab^]P[:Thb)
ecUTQc\Y^UcU\USd[UicQ^T]Qi
Q\c_RU`b_WbQ]]UTQcc`UUTTYQ\_bVUQdebUQSSUcc
[Uic
#
<4BB064:Th)
V_bcU^TY^WQ^TbUc`_^TY^Wd_
]UccQWUc
$
7>;3
:Th
bUT[Ui
)
V_b`\QSY^WSQ\\c_^X_\T
%
B?40:4A
:Th)
V_bdeb^Y^WdXUcUdc`UQ[Ub_^Q^T_VV
TebY^W_^X__[_`UbQdY_^
&
0??;820C8>=:Th)
@bUcU^d\i^_dQSdYfU
'
<82A>?7>=4:Th)
V_bdeb^Y^WdXU]YSb_`X_^U_^_b
_VVQ`bYfQSiVUQdebUTebY^WQ^_^X__[SQ\\
(
E>;D<4C>=42>=CA0BC
∧
:ThP]S
E>;D<4
C>=42>=CA0BC
∨
:Th)
V_bSXQ^WY^WdXUf_\e]U
_VdXUXQ^TcUdbUSUYfUbdXUf_\e]UQ^T`YdSX_VdXU
bY^WUbQ^TQTZecdY^WdXUS_^dbQcd_VdXU=QY^4Yc`\Qi
;X]TBcPcdb3Xb_[Ph)
cX_gcgXYSX@Ubc_^Q\;UicQbU
QSdYfUQ^TdXUYbcdQdec
<PX]3Xb_[Ph)
cX_gcCe`Ub;UiY^cdbeSdY_^cQ^T
C_Vd[Ui\QRU\cdY]UQ^TTQdUSQ\\cdQdec]UccQWY^W
Q^TcicdU]Ubb_bY^V_b]QdY_^
!
<TbbPVT;P\_)
GXU^V\QcXY^WYdY^TYSQdUcdXQdQ
]UccQWUYcgQYdY^WGXU^\YdTebY^WQSQ\\dXU^Q
]UccQWUSQ^RUcU^d
"
<XRa^_W^]T;P\_)
GXU^\YdYdY^TYSQdUcdXQddXU
]YSb_`X_^UYc_^
;X]T0__TPaP]RTbP]S?Tab^]P[:Thb
I_eb
CE@5BC5D$#
dU\U`X_^USQ^QSS_]]_TQdUe`d_
!"\Y^UcY^S\eTY^Wi_eb`bY]U\Y^Ui_eb\YcdUT^e]RUb1
@Ubc_^Q\;UiSQ^RU`b_WbQ]]UTQcQ<Y^UCU\USd;Uid_
QSSUccQdU\U`X_^U\Y^UY^gXYSXSQcUi_egY\\XQfUQ^
²Q``UQbQ^SU³_VdXU\Y^U\_SQdUTY^dXU<Y^UCdQdec4Yc`\Qi
TYbUSd\iQSb_ccVb_]UQSX<Y^UCU\USd;Ui
I_eSQ^QSSUccQ^_dXUb\Y^UZecdRi`bUccY^WdXU<Y^UCU\USd
;UiV_bYdDXU<Y^U1``UQbQ^SUY^TYSQd_bccX_gi_edXU
cdQdec_VdXU\Y^UcgXYSXi_eXQfU`b_WbQ]]UT_^i_ebcUd
FWT]P[X]TXb cWT[X]TP__TPaP]RTXb
9T\U _VV
2eci c_\YT_^
BY^WY^W V\QcXY^Wc\_g\i
?^X_\TQdi_ebcUd V\QcXY^WbQ`YT\i
?^X_\TQdQ^_dXUbcUd V\QcXY^WY^Qc\_g_^VQcd_VVSiS\U
_^i_ebcUdµc<Y^U1``UQbQ^SU
1@Ubc_^Q\;UiSQ^Q\c_RU`b_WbQ]]UTQcQ6UQdebU;Ui
V_baeYS[QSSUccd_Q^_VdU^ecUTVUQdebUGXU^dXQd[Ui
Yc`bUccUTd_deb^_^dXUVUQdebUdXU<Y^U1``UQbQ^SUV_b
dXQd[UigY\\deb^_^
5TPcdaTb=^c0ePX[PQ[T
DXUbU]QiRU`b_SUTebUcY^dXYcWeYTUgXYSXi_eSQ^^_d
`UbV_b]_^i_ebdU\U`X_^UcUdDXYcYcRUSQecUi_eb
S_]`Q^iXQcc`USYQ\\icU\USdUTi_ebVUQdebUcQ^TSQ\\Y^W
`bYfY\UWUc
DXUVUQdebUgY\\^_dQ``UQbYVYdXQc^_dRUU^U^QR\UTCUU
i_eb3_]]e^YSQdY_^c4U`Qbd]U^dYVi_eXQfUQ^i
aeUcdY_^c
<PZX]V2P[[b
4YQ\Y^WVb_]i_eb
CE@5BC5D$!
YcTYVVUbU^dTU`U^TY^W
_^gXUdXUbi_ebdU\U`X_^UcicdU]_`UbQdUcQcQ@2H_b
QcQ;UiDU\U`X_^UCicdU];DC
1cQ@2HTYQ\Y^WYcUhQSd\idXUcQ]UQcTYQ\Y^WVb_]Q^i
_dXUbdU\U`X_^U:ecdecUdXUTYQ\`QTd_TYQ\dXU^e]RUb
Y^S\eTY^WQ^i_edcYTUQSSUccS_TUeceQ\\idXU^e]RUb²)³
YVbUaeYbUT
1cQ;DCd_]Q[UQ^_edcYTUSQ\\i_e]ecdVYbcd`bUccQ
<Y^U[Uid_cU\USdQ^_edcYTU\Y^URUV_bUTYQ\Y^WD_]Q[U
Q^Y^dUb^Q\SQ\\@2HQ^T;DCcY]`\iTYQ\dXUUhdU^cY_^
^e]RUb
1^cgUbY^WY^dUb^Q\SQ\\cYcQ\c_UhQSd\idXUcQ]UQc
Q^cgUbY^WSQ\\cVb_]Q^i_dXUbdU\U`X_^U±Zecd\YVddXU
XQ^TcUd<Y[UgYcUV_b_edcYTUSQ\\cY^Q@2HD_Q^cgUbQ^
_edcYTUSQ\\Y^Q;DCi_e]ecd`bUccdXUV\QcXY^W<Y^U[Ui
QVdUb\YVdY^WdXUXQ^TcUd
4YQ\Y^WVb_]i_eb
CE@5BC5D$"
YcUhQSd\idXUcQ]UQc
TYQ\Y^WVb_]Q^i_dXUbdU\U`X_^U:ecdecUdXUTYQ\`QTd_
TYQ\dXU^e]RUbY^S\eTY^WQ^i_edcYTUQSSUccS_TU
eceQ\\idXU^e]RUb´´)µµYVbUaeYbUT
2^aaTRcX]VP3XP[X]V4aa^a
1c\_^WQcdXUQbb_g
←
c_Vd[UiQ``UQbcY^i_ebTYc`\Qi
i_eSQ^S_bbUSdQTYQ\Y^WUbb_bCY]`\i`bUcc
←
d_UbQcU
dXUY^S_bbUSdTYWYdc+dXU^U^dUbdXUS_bbUSdTYWYdcVb_]dXU
TYQ\`QTY^dXU^_b]Q\VQcXY_^
